pSEOBNRv4HM_tgr-review.md

@@ -110,6 +110,11 @@ Abhirup, Roland, Richard, Max, Gregorio
 
 *Minutes*  
  
+- Gregorio gave an overview on the status of the review and various action items for the reviewers (see below).
+- Gregorio asked if there was any issue (in the non-spinning implementation) with the ringdown attachment when leaving the whole omega_GR*(1+domega) free.
+- Richard mentioned that the attachment could become non-smooth if the non-GR parameters (domega and dtau) are very far from the GR waveform. Richard mentioned that plotting the waveform for several values of domega and dtau would serve to check for which intervals of domega and dtau is the waveform sane. 
+- Discussion about the injection set that we want to use to test the code. Proposals to be written down in the wiki.
+
 *Action items*  
 
 - Reviewers to fill in info on how to run the test;  
@@ -121,6 +126,12 @@ Abhirup, Roland, Richard, Max, Gregorio
 1. Corner plots with (Mf,af,domega)   
 2. A plot showing (Mf,af) from a GR run vs the ones recovered when domega was varying.  
 (These plots are to check that a deviation in Mf does not compensate a deviation in domega in such a way that omega(Mf,af)*(1+domega) still matches the GR prediction) 
+3. Plots of the waveform for several values of domega and dtau to make sure that waveform look sane.
+- Abhirup and Richard to provide config files to run on injection set.
+
+*Conclusions and future plans* 
+
+- Meet during GR22 to review config files and launch runs on injections.  
 
 ***19/06/2019***