Changes

Page history
Update 021323 authored by Prathamesh Joshi's avatar Prathamesh Joshi
Hide whitespace changes
Inline Side-by-side
021323.md
View page @ 99c45c63
......@@ -97,75 +97,75 @@ Char / Minute Taker / Focus Session [Rota](https://git.ligo.org/groups/gstlal/-/
## Chat log
<13:39:36> "Divya Singh": we didn't get a chance to look into this
<13:44:50> "Prathamesh Joshi": yep, will do
<13:44:59> "Victoria Niu": https://git.ligo.org/gstlal/online-analysis/-/issues/140
<13:45:07> "ryan.magee": none here
<13:45:28> "Becca Ewing": https://gstlal.ligo.caltech.edu/grafana/d/vlTWYqAVz/new-and-improved-test-suite?orgId=1&var-DashDatasource=toggle_far_test&var-far=oneperhour&from=now-24h&to=now&var-pastro_name=gstlal
<13:46:35> "Shio.Sakon": no updates
<13:47:16> "Leo Tsukada": https://git.ligo.org/lscsoft/gstlal/-/merge_requests/395
<13:48:59> "jolien.creighton": hand up
<13:49:43> "Leo Tsukada": I am wondering too
<13:50:56> "Leo Tsukada": that is all
<13:51:23> "Shio.Sakon": hand up
<13:52:22> "Cort Posnansky": hand up
<13:53:24> "Rachael Huxford": nothing
<13:54:06> "stefano.schmidt": https://ldas-jobs.ligo.caltech.edu/~stefano.schmidt/gstlal/testrun_20230119_precession/money_plots.html
<13:54:52> "Leo Tsukada": how new is the branch you are using?
<13:54:59> "Leo Tsukada": or how different it is from master
<13:55:16> "Leo Tsukada": okay,
<13:55:26> "ryan.magee": are you expecting this branch to produce good closed box for precession? Or is this an aligned spin test?
<13:57:32> "Rachael Huxford": Can you share the path to this run in a mattermost channel?
<13:58:13> "Cody Messick": sorry how long was it
<13:58:23> "Rachael Huxford": I think they said a day or two
<13:58:45> "Cody Messick": i think at 20k template you'd need 10 days to get a decent IFAR plot
<13:59:01> "Cody Messick": at least
<13:59:06> "stefano.schmidt": I see so nothing to worry about! Thanks
<13:59:23> "stefano.schmidt": (yet)
<13:59:38> "Divya Singh": is anyone speaking?
<13:59:43> "Cody Messick": haha yeah, yet. But the missed found plots look reasonable for the point it's at, so that's hopefully a good sign
<14:02:14> "Leo Tsukada": I have some script that does the reconstruction
<14:02:32> "Leo Tsukada": okay
<14:03:31> "Divya Singh": https://lscsoft.docs.ligo.org/gstlal/tutorials/gstlal_fake_data_overview.html#simulated-data-tutorial
<14:03:50> "Rachael Huxford": yeah I believe so
<14:04:46> "Rachael Huxford": I think instead of devshm you need to provide like white or something?
<14:04:52> "ryan.magee": Yeah I think so, i've never tried running that offline though. It might be online mode only
<14:05:09> "Divya Singh": https://git.ligo.org/lscsoft/gstlal/-/blob/master/gstlal/python/datasource.py#L731 give white here?
<14:05:23> "jolien.creighton": presumably you need to tell it what psd to use
<14:05:29> "jolien.creighton": (since it can't be measured)
<14:05:31> "stefano.schmidt": right!
<14:06:04> "Shio.Sakon": I forgot one thing about the LR. I'm working on printing out the individual LR components when one gives "--verbose" when running commands for the gstlal_inspiral_calc_likelihood code. Not quite in shape yet. Planning to make an MR so that it's part of the code, and usable.
<14:07:01> "Leo Tsukada": hand up
<14:07:06> "Rachael Huxford": can you not put it once in the numerator and once in the denominator code maybe?
<14:08:02> "Shio.Sakon": hand up
<14:08:42> "Leo Tsukada": okay
<14:08:45> "Leo Tsukada": sounds good
<14:09:05> "Rachael Huxford": hand up
<14:09:43> "Rachael Huxford": https://git.ligo.org/lscsoft/gstlal/-/blob/master/gstlal-inspiral/python/workflows/templates/Makefile.online_inspiral_template#L114
<14:10:26> "Becca Ewing": hand up
<14:11:15> "Leo Tsukada": hand up
<14:11:53> "Rachael Huxford": https://git.ligo.org/lscsoft/gstlal/-/blob/master/gstlal-inspiral/python/workflows/templates/Makefile.online_inspiral_template#L144
<14:11:56> "Rachael Huxford": ^^ like this
<14:14:41> "ryan.magee": I thought at like O(10 Mpc) but that might be old info.
<14:16:19> "Leo Tsukada": no updates for LR paper
<14:16:26> "Rachael Huxford": none for iDQ
<14:16:53> "Shio.Sakon": planning to do a poster on the O4 temp bank stuff in the LVK march mtg
<14:16:58> "Divya Singh": hand up
<14:17:10> "Becca Ewing": i was
<14:17:16> "Becca Ewing": yes
<14:19:39> "jolien.creighton": hand up
<14:22:12> "ryan.magee": well also, this is online inj right?
<14:22:22> "Leo Tsukada": does anyone remember the clustering window?
<14:22:43> "ryan.magee": LR is 4 s? We keep switching it
<14:22:50> "Cody Messick": it was +- 4 seconds unless it got changed
<14:23:24> "Leo Tsukada": thanks
<14:23:26> "ryan.magee": Still 4 s https://git.ligo.org/lscsoft/gstlal/-/blob/master/gstlal-inspiral/share/simplify_and_cluster.sql#L206
<14:24:20> "ryan.magee": hopefully
<14:25:31> "Cody Messick": I feel like...yeah it's gotta be fine
<14:25:43> "Cody Messick": the correlation between templates goes down really quickly right
<14:26:02> "Cody Messick": like i bet the biggest risk would be having two waveforms with very similar parameters, but a wide distribution makes that way less likely
<14:26:08> "Divya Singh": https://git.ligo.org/RatesAndPopulations/o4-plan-investigations/-/blob/o4-injection-proposal/o4-injection-proposal/o4-injection-scope.md
<14:26:12> "Cody Messick": so my money is on 7 seconds would be fine full stop
<14:27:19> "Leo Tsukada": 3600*24*30*18/7 = 6M
<14:30:16> "Leo Tsukada": I am curious the mimum interval in the inejction set
<14:32:31> "Leo Tsukada": Prathamesh!
\ No newline at end of file
- <13:39:36> "Divya Singh": we didn't get a chance to look into this
- <13:44:50> "Prathamesh Joshi": yep, will do
- <13:44:59> "Victoria Niu": https://git.ligo.org/gstlal/online-analysis/-/issues/140
- <13:45:07> "ryan.magee": none here
- <13:45:28> "Becca Ewing": https://gstlal.ligo.caltech.edu/grafana/d/vlTWYqAVz/new-and-improved-test-suite?orgId=1&var-DashDatasource=toggle_far_test&var-far=oneperhour&from=now-24h&to=now&var-pastro_name=gstlal
- <13:46:35> "Shio.Sakon": no updates
- <13:47:16> "Leo Tsukada": https://git.ligo.org/lscsoft/gstlal/-/merge_requests/395
- <13:48:59> "jolien.creighton": hand up
- <13:49:43> "Leo Tsukada": I am wondering too
- <13:50:56> "Leo Tsukada": that is all
- <13:51:23> "Shio.Sakon": hand up
- <13:52:22> "Cort Posnansky": hand up
- <13:53:24> "Rachael Huxford": nothing
- <13:54:06> "stefano.schmidt": https://ldas-jobs.ligo.caltech.edu/~stefano.schmidt/gstlal/testrun_20230119_precession/money_plots.html
- <13:54:52> "Leo Tsukada": how new is the branch you are using?
- <13:54:59> "Leo Tsukada": or how different it is from master
- <13:55:16> "Leo Tsukada": okay,
- <13:55:26> "ryan.magee": are you expecting this branch to produce good closed box for precession? Or is this an aligned spin test?
- <13:57:32> "Rachael Huxford": Can you share the path to this run in a mattermost channel?
- <13:58:13> "Cody Messick": sorry how long was it
- <13:58:23> "Rachael Huxford": I think they said a day or two
- <13:58:45> "Cody Messick": i think at 20k template you'd need 10 days to get a decent IFAR plot
- <13:59:01> "Cody Messick": at least
- <13:59:06> "stefano.schmidt": I see so nothing to worry about! Thanks
- <13:59:23> "stefano.schmidt": (yet)
- <13:59:38> "Divya Singh": is anyone speaking?
- <13:59:43> "Cody Messick": haha yeah, yet. But the missed found plots look reasonable for the point it's at, so that's hopefully a good sign
- <14:02:14> "Leo Tsukada": I have some script that does the reconstruction
- <14:02:32> "Leo Tsukada": okay
- <14:03:31> "Divya Singh": https://lscsoft.docs.ligo.org/gstlal/tutorials/gstlal_fake_data_overview.html#simulated-data-tutorial
- <14:03:50> "Rachael Huxford": yeah I believe so
- <14:04:46> "Rachael Huxford": I think instead of devshm you need to provide like white or something?
- <14:04:52> "ryan.magee": Yeah I think so, i've never tried running that offline though. It might be online mode only
- <14:05:09> "Divya Singh": https://git.ligo.org/lscsoft/gstlal/-/blob/master/gstlal/python/datasource.py#L731 give white here?
- <14:05:23> "jolien.creighton": presumably you need to tell it what psd to use
- <14:05:29> "jolien.creighton": (since it can't be measured)
- <14:05:31> "stefano.schmidt": right!
- <14:06:04> "Shio.Sakon": I forgot one thing about the LR. I'm working on printing out the individual LR components when one gives "--verbose" when running commands for the gstlal_inspiral_calc_likelihood code. Not quite in shape yet. Planning to make an MR so that it's part of the code, and usable.
- <14:07:01> "Leo Tsukada": hand up
- <14:07:06> "Rachael Huxford": can you not put it once in the numerator and once in the denominator code maybe?
- <14:08:02> "Shio.Sakon": hand up
- <14:08:42> "Leo Tsukada": okay
- <14:08:45> "Leo Tsukada": sounds good
- <14:09:05> "Rachael Huxford": hand up
- <14:09:43> "Rachael Huxford": https://git.ligo.org/lscsoft/gstlal/-/blob/master/gstlal-inspiral/python/workflows/templates/Makefile.online_inspiral_template#L114
- <14:10:26> "Becca Ewing": hand up
- <14:11:15> "Leo Tsukada": hand up
- <14:11:53> "Rachael Huxford": https://git.ligo.org/lscsoft/gstlal/-/blob/master/gstlal-inspiral/python/workflows/templates/Makefile.online_inspiral_template#L144
- <14:11:56> "Rachael Huxford": ^^ like this
- <14:14:41> "ryan.magee": I thought at like O(10 Mpc) but that might be old info.
- <14:16:19> "Leo Tsukada": no updates for LR paper
- <14:16:26> "Rachael Huxford": none for iDQ
- <14:16:53> "Shio.Sakon": planning to do a poster on the O4 temp bank stuff in the LVK march mtg
- <14:16:58> "Divya Singh": hand up
- <14:17:10> "Becca Ewing": i was
- <14:17:16> "Becca Ewing": yes
- <14:19:39> "jolien.creighton": hand up
- <14:22:12> "ryan.magee": well also, this is online inj right?
- <14:22:22> "Leo Tsukada": does anyone remember the clustering window?
- <14:22:43> "ryan.magee": LR is 4 s? We keep switching it
- <14:22:50> "Cody Messick": it was +- 4 seconds unless it got changed
- <14:23:24> "Leo Tsukada": thanks
- <14:23:26> "ryan.magee": Still 4 s https://git.ligo.org/lscsoft/gstlal/-/blob/master/gstlal-inspiral/share/simplify_and_cluster.sql#L206
- <14:24:20> "ryan.magee": hopefully
- <14:25:31> "Cody Messick": I feel like...yeah it's gotta be fine
- <14:25:43> "Cody Messick": the correlation between templates goes down really quickly right
- <14:26:02> "Cody Messick": like i bet the biggest risk would be having two waveforms with very similar parameters, but a wide distribution makes that way less likely
- <14:26:08> "Divya Singh": https://git.ligo.org/RatesAndPopulations/o4-plan-investigations/-/blob/o4-injection-proposal/o4-injection-proposal/o4-injection-scope.md
- <14:26:12> "Cody Messick": so my money is on 7 seconds would be fine full stop
- <14:27:19> "Leo Tsukada": 3600*24*30*18/7 = 6M
- <14:30:16> "Leo Tsukada": I am curious the mimum interval in the inejction set
- <14:32:31> "Leo Tsukada": Prathamesh!
\ No newline at end of file