|
|
|No.| NAME | Comments on config ini file|Comments on results from the reviewer | Reviewees comments |
|
|
|No.| NAME | Comments on config ini file|Comments on results from the reviewer | Reviewees comments |
|
|
|
|---| ---- | ---- | ---- | --- |
|
|
|---| ---- | ---- | ---- | --- |
|
|
|
|1. |GW190408a||<br> Anuradha:<br> <br> ks_pos/ks_sym: The logL is different. S1z and S2z are broader than BBH run, and hence effective spin is broader than BBH run. Mtotal and Mc are shifted towards lower values. <br> ||
|
|
|1. |[GW190408a](https://git.ligo.org/nv.krishnendu/lalsuite/-/wikis/O3a-Spin-Quadrupole-BH-mimicker-test-results/S190408a)||<br> Anuradha:<br> <br> ks_pos/ks_sym: The logL is different. S1z and S2z are broader than BBH run, and hence effective spin is broader than BBH run. Mtotal and Mc are shifted towards lower values. <br> ||
|
|
|
|2. |GW190412m||<br> Anuradha: <br> BBH run: Why log L is so different?<br>ks_pos: Why log L is so different? cos(alpha) is very different. chi_eff, q and Mc have shifted towards lower values. Mtotal and m1 are railing at the lower side. <br>ks_sym: Why log L is so different? Mtotal and m1 are railing at the lower side. q has shifted to higher values. ||
|
|
|2. |[GW190412m](https://git.ligo.org/nv.krishnendu/lalsuite/-/wikis/O3a-Spin-Quadrupole-BH-mimicker-test-results/S190412m)||<br> Anuradha: <br> BBH run: Why log L is so different?<br>ks_pos: Why log L is so different? cos(alpha) is very different. chi_eff, q and Mc have shifted towards lower values. Mtotal and m1 are railing at the lower side. <br>ks_sym: Why log L is so different? Mtotal and m1 are railing at the lower side. q has shifted to higher values. ||
|
|
|
|3. |GW190425z||||
|
|
|3. |[GW190425z](https://git.ligo.org/nv.krishnendu/lalsuite/-/wikis/O3a-Spin-Quadrupole-BH-mimicker-test-results/S190425z)||||
|
|
|
|4.|GW190512b||<br> <br> Anuradha: BBH: Why log L is different? ||
|
|
|4.|[GW190512b](https://git.ligo.org/nv.krishnendu/lalsuite/-/wikis/O3a-Spin-Quadrupole-BH-mimicker-test-results/S190512at)||<br> <br> Anuradha: BBH: Why log L is different? ||
|
|
|
|5.|GW190521r||||
|
|
|5.|[GW190521r](https://git.ligo.org/nv.krishnendu/lalsuite/-/wikis/O3a-Spin-Quadrupole-BH-mimicker-test-results/S190412m)||||
|
|
|
|6.|GW190630a||||
|
|
|6.|[GW190630a](https://git.ligo.org/nv.krishnendu/lalsuite/-/wikis/O3a-Spin-Quadrupole-BH-mimicker-test-results/S190630a)||||
|
|
|
|7.|GW190707a||||
|
|
|7.|[GW190707a](https://git.ligo.org/nv.krishnendu/lalsuite/-/wikis/O3a-Spin-Quadrupole-BH-mimicker-test-results/S190707q)||||
|
|
|
|8.|GW190708a ||<br> Anuradha: <br> BBH: Why log L, a1, a1z, and a2z are different? <br>ks_pos: a1z, and a2z are different. a1, a2 are totally unconstrained. 1D ks plot is missing on the posplots.html page. <br> ks_sym: a1z, a2z, a1, a2 are unconstrained. 1D ks plot is missing on the posplots.html page. ||
|
|
|8.|[GW190708a](https://git.ligo.org/nv.krishnendu/lalsuite/-/wikis/O3a-Spin-Quadrupole-BH-mimicker-test-results/S190708ap) ||<br> Anuradha: <br> BBH: Why log L, a1, a1z, and a2z are different? <br>ks_pos: a1z, and a2z are different. a1, a2 are totally unconstrained. 1D ks plot is missing on the posplots.html page. <br> ks_sym: a1z, a2z, a1, a2 are unconstrained. 1D ks plot is missing on the posplots.html page. ||
|
|
|
|9.|GW190720a||||
|
|
|9.|[GW190720a](https://git.ligo.org/nv.krishnendu/lalsuite/-/wikis/O3a-Spin-Quadrupole-BH-mimicker-test-results/S190720a)||||
|
|
|
|10.|GW190728a||||
|
|
|10.|[GW190728a](https://git.ligo.org/nv.krishnendu/lalsuite/-/wikis/O3a-Spin-Quadrupole-BH-mimicker-test-results/S190728q)||||
|
|
|
|11.|GW190814a ||||
|
|
|11.|[GW190814a](https://git.ligo.org/nv.krishnendu/lalsuite/-/wikis/O3a-Spin-Quadrupole-BH-mimicker-test-results/S190814bv) ||||
|
|
|
|12.|GW190828a ||<br> Anuradha: BBH: All parameters are different. You BBH runs is actually better. Prod results are bad, why? <br> ks_pos: Since Prod results are bad, I can not compare. 1D ks plot is missing on the posplots.html page. <br> ks_sym: Since Prod results are bad, I can not compare. 1D ks plot is missing on the posplots.html page. ||
|
|
|12.|[GW190828a](https://git.ligo.org/nv.krishnendu/lalsuite/-/wikis/O3a-Spin-Quadrupole-BH-mimicker-test-results/S190828j) ||<br> Anuradha: BBH: All parameters are different. You BBH runs is actually better. Prod results are bad, why? <br> ks_pos: Since Prod results are bad, I can not compare. 1D ks plot is missing on the posplots.html page. <br> ks_sym: Since Prod results are bad, I can not compare. 1D ks plot is missing on the posplots.html page. ||
|
|
|
|13.|GW190924a||<br> Anuradha: <br> BBH: m1 and mtotal are railing at the boundary. <br>ks_pos: I hope it is a typo, it says BBH vs PE run. m1, m2 and mtotal are railing at the boundary. 1D ks plot is missing on the posplots.html page. <br> ks_sym: mtotal is railing at the boundary. 1D ks plot is missing on the posplots.html page. ||
|
|
|13.|[GW190924a](https://git.ligo.org/nv.krishnendu/lalsuite/-/wikis/O3a-Spin-Quadrupole-BH-mimicker-test-results/S190924h)||<br> Anuradha: <br> BBH: m1 and mtotal are railing at the boundary. <br>ks_pos: I hope it is a typo, it says BBH vs PE run. m1, m2 and mtotal are railing at the boundary. 1D ks plot is missing on the posplots.html page. <br> ks_sym: mtotal is railing at the boundary. 1D ks plot is missing on the posplots.html page. ||
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
**Details of O1/O2 events**
|
|
**Details of O1/O2 events**
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|No.| NAME | Comments on config ini file|Comments on results | Reviewees comments |
|
|
|No.| NAME | Comments on config ini file|Comments on results | Reviewees comments |
|
|
|
|---| ---- | ---- | ---- | --- |
|
|
|---| ---- | ---- | ---- | --- |
|
|
|
|1. |GW150914 | |||
|
|
|1. |[GW150914](https://git.ligo.org/nv.krishnendu/lalsuite/-/wikis/O3a-Spin-Quadrupole-BH-mimicker-test-results/GW150914) | |||
|
|
|
|2. |GW151226 | |||
|
|
|2. |[GW151226](https://git.ligo.org/nv.krishnendu/lalsuite/-/wikis/O3a-Spin-Quadrupole-BH-mimicker-test-results/GW151226) | |||
|
|
|
|3. |GW170104 | |||
|
|
|3. |[GW170104](https://git.ligo.org/nv.krishnendu/lalsuite/-/wikis/O3a-Spin-Quadrupole-BH-mimicker-test-results/GW170104) | |||
|
|
|
|4. |GW170608 | |<br> Anuradha: <br> BBH: Why log L is different? <br>ks_pos: Why log L is different? a2 is unconstrained. m1, m2 and mtotal are railing at the boundary. 1D ks plot is missing on the posplots.html page. <br>ks_sym: Why log L is different? a2 is unconstrained. m1, m2 and mtotal are railing at the boundary. 1D ks plot is missing on the posplots.html page.||
|
|
|4. |[GW170608](https://git.ligo.org/nv.krishnendu/lalsuite/-/wikis/O3a-Spin-Quadrupole-BH-mimicker-test-results/GW170608) | |<br> Anuradha: <br> BBH: Why log L is different? <br>ks_pos: Why log L is different? a2 is unconstrained. m1, m2 and mtotal are railing at the boundary. 1D ks plot is missing on the posplots.html page. <br>ks_sym: Why log L is different? a2 is unconstrained. m1, m2 and mtotal are railing at the boundary. 1D ks plot is missing on the posplots.html page.||
|
|
|
|5. |GW170814 | ||| |
|
|5. |[GW170814](https://git.ligo.org/nv.krishnendu/lalsuite/-/wikis/O3a-Spin-Quadrupole-BH-mimicker-test-results/GW170814) | ||| |
