O3a-Spin-Quadrupole-BH-mimicker-test-results/o3a-review-report.md

@@ -9,7 +9,7 @@
 |No.| NAME | Comments on config ini file|Comments on results from the reviewer | Reviewee comments |Final status|PSD issue affected or not|
 |---| ---- | ---- |  ---- | --- |--- |----|
 |1. |[GW190408a](https://git.ligo.org/nv.krishnendu/lalsuite/-/wikis/O3a-Spin-Quadrupole-BH-mimicker-test-results/S190408a)<br> person responsible: Krishnendu| Prod0/5 OK. <br> Anuradha: OK.| Archisman: No mtot railing. SIQM light railing against prior which is an usual feature. **SIGNED OFF!** <br><br> Anuradha: **SIGNED OFF!**<br><br> Archisman: sym 3 chains OK. pos 4 chains OK. | | **SIGNED OFF!**|Yes, reruns finished and results are uploaded|
-|2. |[GW190412m](https://git.ligo.org/nv.krishnendu/lalsuite/-/wikis/O3a-Spin-Quadrupole-BH-mimicker-test-results/S190412m)<br> person responsible: Krishnendu| Prod0 OK. Anuradha: OK.| Archisman: No mtot railing. SIQM **sym and pos result pages appear to have been swapped. <br><br> <br> Krishnendu: fixed ** <br><br> Anuradha: sym and pos comparison pages are not opening, **please fix**. dkappas_pos plot is **not provided**. In sym run, **ACF** for m1, m2, mtot, eta, iota, theta_JN, a, theta1, s1z, chi_eff look suspicious.<br><br>Krishnendu: dkappas_pos plot is **not provided**:  please see the cbcBayesPostProc page linked from the event page. From example, [here](https://ldas-jobs.ligo.caltech.edu/~nv.krishnendu/LSC/lalinference/O3/o3_a_tgr/S190412m/pv2_c01_prod/psd_rerun/ks_pos/1239082262.17-0/V1H1L1/posplots.html) <br> ACF issues affected or not? <br><br> Archisman: sym 4 chains; chain 3 samples below q=0.2. pos 3 chains; not very identical for some params. <br><br>Anuradha (on reruns): In pos, the sampling of m1, m2, mtot, eta, titl2, S2z look suspesious.  |||Yes, reruns finished and results are uploaded|
+|2. |[GW190412m](https://git.ligo.org/nv.krishnendu/lalsuite/-/wikis/O3a-Spin-Quadrupole-BH-mimicker-test-results/S190412m)<br> person responsible: Krishnendu| Prod0 OK. Anuradha: OK.| Archisman: No mtot railing. SIQM **sym and pos result pages appear to have been swapped. <br><br> <br> Krishnendu: fixed ** <br><br> Anuradha: sym and pos comparison pages are not opening, **please fix**. dkappas_pos plot is **not provided**. In sym run, **ACF** for m1, m2, mtot, eta, iota, theta_JN, a, theta1, s1z, chi_eff look suspicious.<br><br>Krishnendu: dkappas_pos plot is **not provided**:  please see the cbcBayesPostProc page linked from the event page. From example, [here](https://ldas-jobs.ligo.caltech.edu/~nv.krishnendu/LSC/lalinference/O3/o3_a_tgr/S190412m/pv2_c01_prod/psd_rerun/ks_pos/1239082262.17-0/V1H1L1/posplots.html) <br> ACF issues affected or not? <br><br> Archisman: sym 4 chains; chain 3 samples below q=0.2. pos 3 chains; not very identical for some params. <br><br>Anuradha (on reruns): In pos, the sampling of m1, m2, mtot, eta, titl2, S2z look suspesious. <br><br> Archisman (2020-Sep-21 10:00 CEST): I ham happy with the Pv3HM results. The SIQM plot was circulated privately over email [here](https://ldas-jobs.ligo.caltech.edu/~nv.krishnendu/LSC/lalinference/O3/o3_a_tgr/S190412m/psd_rerun_4/ks_sym/dquadmons.png) but is currently not linked off the event page. I kindly request the analysts to do that. **SIGNED OFF!** |||Yes, reruns finished and results are uploaded|
 |3. |[GW190425z](https://git.ligo.org/nv.krishnendu/lalsuite/-/wikis/O3a-Spin-Quadrupole-BH-mimicker-test-results/S190425z)<br> person responsible: Krishnendu| ||  | **event removed from paper** |Not affcted, RA from the prvious runs|
 |4.|[GW190512b](https://git.ligo.org/nv.krishnendu/lalsuite/-/wikis/O3a-Spin-Quadrupole-BH-mimicker-test-results/S190512at)<br> person responsible: Krishnendu| Prod0 OK. <br> Anuradha: OK.| Archisman: No mtot railing; masses bimodal (particularly for sym). SIQM no neg railing; pos unconstrained. **SIGNED OFF!** <br><br> Anuradha: <br> BBH: tc, t0, \rho_ML, logL, mtot, cos(alpha), Mchirp are different. Do we understand why? <br> sym/pos: Why azimuth, t0, cos(alpha) different? <br> In sym run, the **ACF** for Mc, m2, mtot, a, S1z, S2z, chi_eff, chi_p look suspicious. <br><br>Krishnendu: Differences are expected especially on masses as the total mass prior is different from the PE-Prod run <br> ACF issues affected or not? <br><br> Archisman: sym only 1 chain! pos 4 chains OK. <br><br>Anuradha: The difference in t0, alpha, azimuth is due to the different choice of the first detector. The difference in mass is due different prior choice. **SIGNED OFF!**| | **SIGNED OFF!**|Yes, reruns finished and results are uploaded|
 |5.|[GW190521r](https://git.ligo.org/nv.krishnendu/lalsuite/-/wikis/O3a-Spin-Quadrupole-BH-mimicker-test-results/S190521r) <br> person responsible: Saleem| Prod0 OK. <br>Anuradha: OK.|Anuradha: looks good. **SIGNED OFF!**<br><br> Archisman: No mtot railing. SIQM OK. sym 4 chains OK. pos 4 chains OK. **SIGNED OFF!** |  |**SIGNED OFF!**|Yes, reruns finished and results are uploaded |