O3b-analysis/S191216ap.md

@@ -17,6 +17,35 @@
  | C01:Prod10_run01_sym | IMRPhenomPv2pseudoFourPN | {'[base-config](https://ldas-jobs.ligo.caltech.edu/~sayantani.datta/LSC/lalinference/O3/o3_b_tgr/sim/S191216ap/C01/Prod10/run01/Prod10.ini)', '[sym-config](https://ldas-jobs.ligo.caltech.edu/~sayantani.datta/LSC/lalinference/O3/o3_b_tgr/sim/S191216ap/C01/Prod10/run01/ks_sym/config.ini)'} | {'[LOGIC_sym](https://ldas-jobs.ligo.caltech.edu/~sayantani.datta/LSC/lalinference/O3/o3_b_tgr/sim/SummaryPages/S191216ap/C01/Prod10/run01/LOGIC/LOGIC_sym.txt)', '[diff_sym](https://ldas-jobs.ligo.caltech.edu/~sayantani.datta/LSC/lalinference/O3/o3_b_tgr/sim/SummaryPages/S191216ap/C01/Prod10/run01/LOGIC/diff_sym.txt)'} | {'[cbcbayespostproc](https://ldas-jobs.ligo.caltech.edu/~sayantani.datta/LSC/lalinference/O3/o3_b_tgr/sim/S191216ap/C01/Prod10/run01/ks_sym)', '[PEsummary](https://ldas-jobs.ligo.caltech.edu/~sayantani.datta/LSC/lalinference/O3/o3_b_tgr/sim/SummaryPages/S191216ap/C01/Prod10/run01/sym)'} | [LAPLACE_sym](https://ldas-jobs.ligo.caltech.edu/~sayantani.datta/LSC/lalinference/O3/o3_b_tgr/sim/SummaryPages/S191216ap/C01/Prod10/run01/LAPLACE/LAPLACE_sym.txt) | [bbh vs ks_sym](https://ldas-jobs.ligo.caltech.edu/~sayantani.datta/LSC/lalinference/O3/o3_b_tgr/sim/SummaryPages/S191216ap/C01/Prod10/run01/ComparisonPages) | `CIT:/home/sayantani.datta/LSC/lalinference/O3/o3_b_tgr/sim/S191216ap/C01/Prod10/run01/ks_sym` | Complete |Anuradha: OK. Archisman: **OK.**| Not reviewed | 
  | C01:Prod10_run01_bbh | IMRPhenomPv2pseudoFourPN | {'[bbh-config](https://ldas-jobs.ligo.caltech.edu/~sayantani.datta/LSC/lalinference/O3/o3_b_tgr/sim/S191216ap/C01/Prod10/run01/bbh/config.ini)', '[base-config](https://ldas-jobs.ligo.caltech.edu/~sayantani.datta/LSC/lalinference/O3/o3_b_tgr/sim/S191216ap/C01/Prod10/run01/Prod10.ini)'} | {'[LOGIC_bbh](https://ldas-jobs.ligo.caltech.edu/~sayantani.datta/LSC/lalinference/O3/o3_b_tgr/sim/SummaryPages/S191216ap/C01/Prod10/run01/LOGIC/LOGIC_bbh.txt)', '[diff_bbh](https://ldas-jobs.ligo.caltech.edu/~sayantani.datta/LSC/lalinference/O3/o3_b_tgr/sim/SummaryPages/S191216ap/C01/Prod10/run01/LOGIC/diff_bbh.txt)'} | {'[PEsummary](https://ldas-jobs.ligo.caltech.edu/~sayantani.datta/LSC/lalinference/O3/o3_b_tgr/sim/SummaryPages/S191216ap/C01/Prod10/run01/bbh)', '[cbcbayespostproc](https://ldas-jobs.ligo.caltech.edu/~sayantani.datta/LSC/lalinference/O3/o3_b_tgr/sim/S191216ap/C01/Prod10/run01/bbh)'} | [LAPLACE_bbh](https://ldas-jobs.ligo.caltech.edu/~sayantani.datta/LSC/lalinference/O3/o3_b_tgr/sim/SummaryPages/S191216ap/C01/Prod10/run01/LAPLACE/LAPLACE_bbh.txt) | NA | `CIT:/home/sayantani.datta/LSC/lalinference/O3/o3_b_tgr/sim/S191216ap/C01/Prod10/run01/bbh` | Complete | Anuradha: OK. Archisman: **OK.** | Not reviewed |
 
+
+
+**Some notes on results from able 0  (Final Results)**
+
+Doubts :  
+1) Posteriors on q and m2 from the kappa run show not-so-significant peaks at low and high values.
+2) m2 looks a bit ratty from the kappa run.
+3) The low q mode don't seem to be well-sampled for bbh run. Same for m2.
+4) Mtotal posterior is railing for bbh run.
+
+Discussions:
+
+Archishman: low q- high q regions may be coming from one or few faulty chains:
+
+>> No particular chain seem to be standing out much as can be seen [here](https://ldas-jobs.ligo.caltech.edu/~sayantani.datta/LSC/lalinference/O3/o3_b_tgr/sim/SummaryPages/S191216ap/C01/Prod10/run01/chains/home.html).
+
+[GWTC-3.0 PE. channel on mattermost](https://chat.ligo.org/ligo/pl/du9w99kz1bbotg4m9jy1goi8aa): The regions where there is some trouble sampling might not be showing up for [pbilby](https://ldas-jobs.ligo.caltech.edu/~pe.o3/LVC/o3b-catalog/S191216a/Prod8/results/html/Prod8_Prod8.html) PE runs due to large number of samples. Our bbh run is somewhat consistent with a [preliminary run done with pv2](https://ldas-jobs.ligo.caltech.edu/~hsin-yu.chen/LVC/projects/O3/S191216ap/8s/html/EXP0_EXP0_mass_ratio.html), [Anjali's RIFT run](https://ldas-jobs.ligo.caltech.edu/~anjali.yelikar/O3_PEsumm_RIFT/O3b/S191216a/SEOBNRv4PHM_manual_noprocessing/html/RIFT-SEOBNRv4PHM_RIFT-SEOBNRv4PHM.html). Ajit Mehta did some checks with IMRXPHM comparing LI-mcmc, LI-nest and bilby runs. LI shows a peak at low q that bilby does not, see [here](https://hypatia.aei.mpg.de/~ajit.mehta/LVC/O3b_CBC_TGR/S191216ap/GR/peSummary/4samples/html/Comparison_mass_ratio.html).
+
+As there is a possibility of not so well sampled regions for our runs, I have launched runs with maxmcmc=10000.
+
+## Table 0  (Final Results with maxmcmc=10000)
+
+|  |Waveform |Configs |LOGIC |Results |LAPLACE |Comparison Pages |Run directory |Run status |Review comments |
+ |------ | ------ | ------ | ------ | ------ | ------ | ------ | ------ | ------ | ------ | 
+ | C01:Prod10_run03_bbh | IMRPhenomPv2pseudoFourPN | {'[base-config](https://ldas-jobs.ligo.caltech.edu/~sayantani.datta/LSC/lalinference/O3/o3_b_tgr/sim/S191216ap/C01/Prod10/run03/Prod10.ini)', '[bbh-config](https://ldas-jobs.ligo.caltech.edu/~sayantani.datta/LSC/lalinference/O3/o3_b_tgr/sim/S191216ap/C01/Prod10/run03/bbh/config.ini)'} | {'[LOGIC_bbh](https://ldas-jobs.ligo.caltech.edu/~sayantani.datta/LSC/lalinference/O3/o3_b_tgr/sim/SummaryPages/S191216ap/C01/Prod10/run03/LOGIC/LOGIC_bbh.txt)', '[diff_bbh](https://ldas-jobs.ligo.caltech.edu/~sayantani.datta/LSC/lalinference/O3/o3_b_tgr/sim/SummaryPages/S191216ap/C01/Prod10/run03/LOGIC/diff_bbh.txt)'} | Results NA | Results NA | NA | `CIT:/home/sayantani.datta/LSC/lalinference/O3/o3_b_tgr/sim/S191216ap/C01/Prod10/run03/bbh` | dz: ['42.340', '54.227', '61.429', '73.562', '46.291', 'Resuming', '39.802', '59.500'] | Not reviewed | 
+ | C01:Prod10_run03_sym | IMRPhenomPv2pseudoFourPN | {'[base-config](https://ldas-jobs.ligo.caltech.edu/~sayantani.datta/LSC/lalinference/O3/o3_b_tgr/sim/S191216ap/C01/Prod10/run03/Prod10.ini)', '[sym-config](https://ldas-jobs.ligo.caltech.edu/~sayantani.datta/LSC/lalinference/O3/o3_b_tgr/sim/S191216ap/C01/Prod10/run03/ks_sym/config.ini)'} | {'[LOGIC_sym](https://ldas-jobs.ligo.caltech.edu/~sayantani.datta/LSC/lalinference/O3/o3_b_tgr/sim/SummaryPages/S191216ap/C01/Prod10/run03/LOGIC/LOGIC_sym.txt)', '[diff_sym](https://ldas-jobs.ligo.caltech.edu/~sayantani.datta/LSC/lalinference/O3/o3_b_tgr/sim/SummaryPages/S191216ap/C01/Prod10/run03/LOGIC/diff_sym.txt)'} | Results NA | Results NA | Results NA | `CIT:/home/sayantani.datta/LSC/lalinference/O3/o3_b_tgr/sim/S191216ap/C01/Prod10/run03/ks_sym` | dz: ['88.358', '92.841', '56.003', '61.319', '74.119', '57.236', '72.181', '90.828'] | Not reviewed | 
+
+
+
 ## Table I  (Not Final Results)
 |  |Waveform |Configs |LOGIC |Results |LAPLACE |Comparison Pages |Run directory |Run status |Comments on config files |Comments on results |
  |------ | ------ | ------ | ------ | ------ | ------ | ------ | ------ | ------ | ------ | ------ |