Changes

Page history
Update Additional Review (marginalization over joint population+EoS uncertainty) authored by Reed Essick's avatar Reed Essick
Show whitespace changes
Inline Side-by-side
Additional-Review-(marginalization-over-joint-population+EoS-uncertainty).md
View page @ d4501f4c
......@@ -274,70 +274,86 @@ Below, we compare results obtained for previous (published) LVK analyses with th
Previous results are stored [here](https://git.ligo.org/reed.essick/o3-nsbh-mmax-model-selection/-/tree/master/data) and results obtained with the updated code are stored [here](https://git.ligo.org/reed.essick/mmax-model-selection/-/tree/gw-distributions/test/o3-nsbh/data). **Update link once merge request has been accepted**
I report only a few of the
| event |PE samples|EoS distrib|population|previous results|new results|
|--------|----------|----------|-----------|----------------|-----------|
|GW200105|C01_PHMcombined_highspin|FC-mmax|flat| | |
|GW200105|C01_PHMcombined_highspin|FC-mmax|salpeter| | |
|GW200105|C01_PHMcombined_highspin|FC-mmax|O3a_ALL_BROKEN_POWERLAW| | |
|GW200105|C01_PHMcombined_highspin|FC-mmax|O3a_NO_GW190814_BROKEN_POWERLAW| | |
|GW200105|C01_PHMcombined_highspin|FC-mmax|O3a_ALL_POWERLAW+PEAK| | |
|GW200105|C01_PHMcombined_highspin|FC-mmax|O3a_NO_GW190814_POWERLAW+PEAK| | |
|GW200105|C01_PHMcombined_highspin|LEC-mtov|flat| | |
|GW200105|C01_PHMcombined_highspin|LEC-mtov|salpeter| | |
|GW200105|C01_PHMcombined_highspin|LEC-mtov|O3a_ALL_BROKEN_POWERLAW| | |
|GW200105|C01_PHMcombined_highspin|LEC-mtov|O3a_NO_GW190814_BROKEN_POWERLAW| | |
|GW200105|C01_PHMcombined_highspin|LEC-mtov|O3a_ALL_POWERLAW+PEAK| | |
|GW200105|C01_PHMcombined_highspin|LEC-mtov|O3a_NO_GW190814_POWERLAW+PEAK| | |
|GW200105|C01_PHMcombined_highspin|LEC-mtov-rtov|flat| | |
|GW200105|C01_PHMcombined_highspin|LEC-mtov-rtov|salpeter| | |
|GW200105|C01_PHMcombined_highspin|LEC-mtov-rtov|O3a_ALL_BROKEN_POWERLAW| | |
|GW200105|C01_PHMcombined_highspin|LEC-mtov-rtov|O3a_NO_GW190814_BROKEN_POWERLAW| | |
|GW200105|C01_PHMcombined_highspin|LEC-mtov-rtov|O3a_ALL_POWERLAW+PEAK| | |
|GW200105|C01_PHMcombined_highspin|LEC-mtov-rtov|O3a_NO_GW190814_POWERLAW+PEAK| | |
|GW200105|C01_PHMcombined_lowspin|FC-mmax|flat| | |
|GW200105|C01_PHMcombined_lowspin|FC-mmax|salpeter| | |
|GW200105|C01_PHMcombined_lowspin|FC-mmax|O3a_ALL_BROKEN_POWERLAW| | |
|GW200105|C01_PHMcombined_lowspin|FC-mmax|O3a_NO_GW190814_BROKEN_POWERLAW| | |
|GW200105|C01_PHMcombined_lowspin|FC-mmax|O3a_ALL_POWERLAW+PEAK| | |
|GW200105|C01_PHMcombined_lowspin|FC-mmax|O3a_NO_GW190814_POWERLAW+PEAK| | |
|GW200105|C01_PHMcombined_lowspin|LEC-mtov|flat| | |
|GW200105|C01_PHMcombined_lowspin|LEC-mtov|salpeter| | |
|GW200105|C01_PHMcombined_lowspin|LEC-mtov|O3a_ALL_BROKEN_POWERLAW| | |
|GW200105|C01_PHMcombined_lowspin|LEC-mtov|O3a_NO_GW190814_BROKEN_POWERLAW| | |
|GW200105|C01_PHMcombined_lowspin|LEC-mtov|O3a_ALL_POWERLAW+PEAK| | |
|GW200105|C01_PHMcombined_lowspin|LEC-mtov|O3a_NO_GW190814_POWERLAW+PEAK| | |
|GW200115|C01_PHMcombined_highspin|FC-mmax|flat| | |
|GW200115|C01_PHMcombined_highspin|FC-mmax|salpeter| | |
|GW200115|C01_PHMcombined_highspin|FC-mmax|O3a_ALL_BROKEN_POWERLAW| | |
|GW200115|C01_PHMcombined_highspin|FC-mmax|O3a_NO_GW190814_BROKEN_POWERLAW| | |
|GW200115|C01_PHMcombined_highspin|FC-mmax|O3a_ALL_POWERLAW+PEAK| | |
|GW200115|C01_PHMcombined_highspin|FC-mmax|O3a_NO_GW190814_POWERLAW+PEAK| | |
|GW200115|C01_PHMcombined_highspin|LEC-mtov|flat| | |
|GW200115|C01_PHMcombined_highspin|LEC-mtov|salpeter| | |
|GW200115|C01_PHMcombined_highspin|LEC-mtov|O3a_ALL_BROKEN_POWERLAW| | |
|GW200115|C01_PHMcombined_highspin|LEC-mtov|O3a_NO_GW190814_BROKEN_POWERLAW| | |
|GW200115|C01_PHMcombined_highspin|LEC-mtov|O3a_ALL_POWERLAW+PEAK| | |
|GW200115|C01_PHMcombined_highspin|LEC-mtov|O3a_NO_GW190814_POWERLAW+PEAK| | |
|GW200115|C01_PHMcombined_highspin|LEC-mtov-rtov|flat| | |
|GW200115|C01_PHMcombined_highspin|LEC-mtov-rtov|salpeter| | |
|GW200115|C01_PHMcombined_highspin|LEC-mtov-rtov|O3a_ALL_BROKEN_POWERLAW| | |
|GW200115|C01_PHMcombined_highspin|LEC-mtov-rtov|O3a_NO_GW190814_BROKEN_POWERLAW| | |
|GW200115|C01_PHMcombined_highspin|LEC-mtov-rtov|O3a_ALL_POWERLAW+PEAK| | |
|GW200115|C01_PHMcombined_highspin|LEC-mtov-rtov|O3a_NO_GW190814_POWERLAW+PEAK| | |
|GW200115|C01_PHMcombined_lowspin|FC-mmax|flat| | |
|GW200115|C01_PHMcombined_lowspin|FC-mmax|salpeter| | |
|GW200115|C01_PHMcombined_lowspin|FC-mmax|O3a_ALL_BROKEN_POWERLAW| | |
|GW200115|C01_PHMcombined_lowspin|FC-mmax|O3a_NO_GW190814_BROKEN_POWERLAW| | |
|GW200115|C01_PHMcombined_lowspin|FC-mmax|O3a_ALL_POWERLAW+PEAK| | |
|GW200115|C01_PHMcombined_lowspin|FC-mmax|O3a_NO_GW190814_POWERLAW+PEAK| | |
|GW200115|C01_PHMcombined_lowspin|LEC-mtov|flat| | |
|GW200115|C01_PHMcombined_lowspin|LEC-mtov|salpeter| | |
|GW200115|C01_PHMcombined_lowspin|LEC-mtov|O3a_ALL_BROKEN_POWERLAW| | |
|GW200115|C01_PHMcombined_lowspin|LEC-mtov|O3a_NO_GW190814_BROKEN_POWERLAW| | |
|GW200115|C01_PHMcombined_lowspin|LEC-mtov|O3a_ALL_POWERLAW+PEAK| | |
|GW200115|C01_PHMcombined_lowspin|LEC-mtov|O3a_NO_GW190814_POWERLAW+PEAK| | |
**GW200105 C01_PHMcombined_highspin**
|EoS distrib|population|previous results|new results|
|-----------|----------|----------------|-----------|
|FC-mmax|flat|[`9.297250e-01 +/- 5.623906e-03`](https://git.ligo.org/reed.essick/o3-nsbh-mmax-model-selection/-/blob/master/data/GW200105-C01_PHMcombined_highspin_pesummary-1000-FC-mmax-1000.out#L35)| |
|FC-mmax|salpeter|[`9.232530e-01 +/- 6.246501e-03`](https://git.ligo.org/reed.essick/o3-nsbh-mmax-model-selection/-/blob/master/data/GW200105-C01_PHMcombined_highspin_pesummary-1000-FC-mmax-1000.out#L73)| |
|FC-mmax|O3a_ALL_BROKEN_POWERLAW|[`8.920556e-01 +/- 1.048218e-02`](https://git.ligo.org/reed.essick/o3-nsbh-mmax-model-selection/-/blob/master/data/GW200105-C01_PHMcombined_highspin_pesummary-1000-FC-mmax-1000.out#L115)| |
|FC-mmax|O3a_NO_GW190814_BROKEN_POWERLAW|[`8.298002e-01 +/- 2.587357e-02`](https://git.ligo.org/reed.essick/o3-nsbh-mmax-model-selection/-/blob/master/data/GW200105-C01_PHMcombined_highspin_pesummary-1000-FC-mmax-1000.out#L156)| |
|FC-mmax|O3a_ALL_POWERLAW+PEAK|[`9.408284e-01 +/- 4.708915e-03`](https://git.ligo.org/reed.essick/o3-nsbh-mmax-model-selection/-/blob/master/data/GW200105-C01_PHMcombined_highspin_pesummary-1000-FC-mmax-1000.out#L199)| |
|FC-mmax|O3a_NO_GW190814_POWERLAW+PEAK|[`9.281716e-01 +/- 6.026169e-03`](https://git.ligo.org/reed.essick/o3-nsbh-mmax-model-selection/-/blob/master/data/GW200105-C01_PHMcombined_highspin_pesummary-1000-FC-mmax-1000.out#L199)| |
|LEC-mtov|flat| | |
|LEC-mtov|salpeter| | |
|LEC-mtov|O3a_ALL_BROKEN_POWERLAW| | |
|LEC-mtov|O3a_NO_GW190814_BROKEN_POWERLAW| | |
|LEC-mtov|O3a_ALL_POWERLAW+PEAK| | |
|LEC-mtov|O3a_NO_GW190814_POWERLAW+PEAK| | |
|LEC-mtov-rtov|flat| | |
|LEC-mtov-rtov|salpeter| | |
|LEC-mtov-rtov|O3a_ALL_BROKEN_POWERLAW| | |
|LEC-mtov-rtov|O3a_NO_GW190814_BROKEN_POWERLAW| | |
|LEC-mtov-rtov|O3a_ALL_POWERLAW+PEAK| | |
|LEC-mtov-rtov|O3a_NO_GW190814_POWERLAW+PEAK| | |
**GW200105 C01_PHMcombined_lowspin**
|EoS distrib|population|previous results|new results|
|-----------|----------|----------------|-----------|
|FC-mmax|flat| | |
|FC-mmax|salpeter| | |
|FC-mmax|O3a_ALL_BROKEN_POWERLAW| | |
|FC-mmax|O3a_NO_GW190814_BROKEN_POWERLAW| | |
|FC-mmax|O3a_ALL_POWERLAW+PEAK| | |
|FC-mmax|O3a_NO_GW190814_POWERLAW+PEAK| | |
|LEC-mtov|flat| | |
|LEC-mtov|salpeter| | |
|LEC-mtov|O3a_ALL_BROKEN_POWERLAW| | |
|LEC-mtov|O3a_NO_GW190814_BROKEN_POWERLAW| | |
|LEC-mtov|O3a_ALL_POWERLAW+PEAK| | |
|LEC-mtov|O3a_NO_GW190814_POWERLAW+PEAK| | |
**GW200115 C01_PHMcombined_highspin**
|EoS distrib|population|previous results|new results|
|-----------|----------|----------------|-----------|
|FC-mmax|flat| | |
|FC-mmax|salpeter| | |
|FC-mmax|O3a_ALL_BROKEN_POWERLAW| | |
|FC-mmax|O3a_NO_GW190814_BROKEN_POWERLAW| | |
|FC-mmax|O3a_ALL_POWERLAW+PEAK| | |
|FC-mmax|O3a_NO_GW190814_POWERLAW+PEAK| | |
|LEC-mtov|flat| | |
|LEC-mtov|salpeter| | |
|LEC-mtov|O3a_ALL_BROKEN_POWERLAW| | |
|LEC-mtov|O3a_NO_GW190814_BROKEN_POWERLAW| | |
|LEC-mtov|O3a_ALL_POWERLAW+PEAK| | |
|LEC-mtov|O3a_NO_GW190814_POWERLAW+PEAK| | |
|LEC-mtov-rtov|flat| | |
|LEC-mtov-rtov|salpeter| | |
|LEC-mtov-rtov|O3a_ALL_BROKEN_POWERLAW| | |
|LEC-mtov-rtov|O3a_NO_GW190814_BROKEN_POWERLAW| | |
|LEC-mtov-rtov|O3a_ALL_POWERLAW+PEAK| | |
|LEC-mtov-rtov|O3a_NO_GW190814_POWERLAW+PEAK| | |
**GW200115 C01_PHMcombined_lowspin**
|EoS distrib|population|previous results|new results|
|-----------|----------|----------------|-----------|
|FC-mmax|flat| | |
|FC-mmax|salpeter| | |
|FC-mmax|O3a_ALL_BROKEN_POWERLAW| | |
|FC-mmax|O3a_NO_GW190814_BROKEN_POWERLAW| | |
|FC-mmax|O3a_ALL_POWERLAW+PEAK| | |
|FC-mmax|O3a_NO_GW190814_POWERLAW+PEAK| | |
|LEC-mtov|flat| | |
|LEC-mtov|salpeter| | |
|LEC-mtov|O3a_ALL_BROKEN_POWERLAW| | |
|LEC-mtov|O3a_NO_GW190814_BROKEN_POWERLAW| | |
|LEC-mtov|O3a_ALL_POWERLAW+PEAK| | |
|LEC-mtov|O3a_NO_GW190814_POWERLAW+PEAK| | |
## materials from previous reviews
......
......